clock menu more-arrow no yes

Eater Readers Give Some Under-Appreciated Louisville Pizza Places A Little Love

View as Map

Eater asked for input on what might be some underexposed pizza places around Louisville. (Certain Schnatter-sensitive readers may be relieved to know Papa John's did not make the list.) We appreciate all who contributed to Pizza Week, and will have more pizza input to relate soon. Meanwhile, enjoy this map of a few pizza places that may (or may not) seem unfamiliar.


Read More
Note: Restaurants on this map are listed geographically.

1. Angilo's Pizza

Copy Link
1725 Berry Blvd
Louisville, KY 40215
(502) 367-0580
Visit Website
Angilo’s Pizza "has been serving the Greater Cincinnati area the finest pizzas and hoagies available for nearly 50 years!" In what may be a surprise to Mayor Fisher, "Greater Cincinnati" includes Berry Boulevard. At least one Eater reader is very happy about this.

2. Come Back Inn

Copy Link
909 Swan St
Louisville, KY 40204
(502) 627-1777
Visit Website
Perhaps due to its Germantown location, this "Real Italian - American" restaurant asks "You got a problem with that?" Seems some local pizza fans have no problem at all.

3. DiOrio's Pizza and Pub

Copy Link
919 Baxter Ave
Louisville, KY 40204
(502) 614-8424
Wings, toasted ravioli and more are on the menu along with pizza, which their somewhat generic website says is made with dough "made fresh daily in house." There's a second location on Wallace Avenue.

4. Caffe Classico

Copy Link
2144 Frankfort Ave
Louisville, KY
(502) 895-0076
Visit Website
The eclectic cafe offers "Eggplant Parmesan Pizza" and "Spicy Thai Shrimp Pizza" along with Spanish Tapas, Steak Frites and "Sausages Alemania."

5. Papalinos Pizza

Copy Link
3598 Springhurst Blvd
Louisville, KY 40241
(502) 736-2700
Visit Website
If someone feels Papalinos has been neglected it probably isn't owner Allen Rosenberg, who's busy shuttling between his original Highlands store and his new Springhurst location, complete with its own charcuterie room.

6. Rosie's Pizza

Copy Link
13829 English Villa Dr
Louisville, KY 40245
(502) 244-2484
Visit Website
Eater readers gave big ups to this Middletown pizzeria's garlic-buttery "Hot Knots," which are on the menu along with "The Hawaiian" and "The Whole Lotta Rosie."

1. Angilo's Pizza

1725 Berry Blvd, Louisville, KY 40215
Angilo’s Pizza "has been serving the Greater Cincinnati area the finest pizzas and hoagies available for nearly 50 years!" In what may be a surprise to Mayor Fisher, "Greater Cincinnati" includes Berry Boulevard. At least one Eater reader is very happy about this.
1725 Berry Blvd
Louisville, KY 40215

2. Come Back Inn

909 Swan St, Louisville, KY 40204
Perhaps due to its Germantown location, this "Real Italian - American" restaurant asks "You got a problem with that?" Seems some local pizza fans have no problem at all.
909 Swan St
Louisville, KY 40204

3. DiOrio's Pizza and Pub

919 Baxter Ave, Louisville, KY 40204
Wings, toasted ravioli and more are on the menu along with pizza, which their somewhat generic website says is made with dough "made fresh daily in house." There's a second location on Wallace Avenue.
919 Baxter Ave
Louisville, KY 40204

4. Caffe Classico

2144 Frankfort Ave, Louisville, KY
The eclectic cafe offers "Eggplant Parmesan Pizza" and "Spicy Thai Shrimp Pizza" along with Spanish Tapas, Steak Frites and "Sausages Alemania."
2144 Frankfort Ave
Louisville, KY

5. Papalinos Pizza

3598 Springhurst Blvd, Louisville, KY 40241
If someone feels Papalinos has been neglected it probably isn't owner Allen Rosenberg, who's busy shuttling between his original Highlands store and his new Springhurst location, complete with its own charcuterie room.
3598 Springhurst Blvd
Louisville, KY 40241

6. Rosie's Pizza

13829 English Villa Dr, Louisville, KY 40245
Eater readers gave big ups to this Middletown pizzeria's garlic-buttery "Hot Knots," which are on the menu along with "The Hawaiian" and "The Whole Lotta Rosie."
13829 English Villa Dr
Louisville, KY 40245